DIFFERENTIATIONS OF REASON

What Can I Know?

What Ought I to do?

What Can I Hope For?

Epistemology

Moral Theory

Aesthetic

Theoretical Reason:

Truth

Practical Reason:

Right or Good

Aesthetic Reason:

Beauty & the Sublime

The role of reason in gaining knowledge

The role of reason in determining action

The role of reason in aesthetic contemplation

Critique of Pure Reason

[1781/1787]

Critique of Practical Reason [1788]

Critique of Judgment

[1790]

Knowledge of Nature

Moral conduct in Society

Imaginative contemplation of Beauty/History

Self-conscious life: Knowledge of the natural world.

Self-determined action: Freedom or autonomy in the social world

Self-realization: authentic or genuine expression within the imagination

Apprehension within intuition, and recognition within the concept

 

Reproduction within the imagination

 

 

 

THE 19TH-CENTURY'S CRITICAL REINTERPRETATION

OF KANT'S COPERNICAN TURN IN PHILOSOPHY

Kant initiates the famous reflexive turn to "world-constituting subjectivity," to a self that forms or "synthesizes" experience according to various concepts or ideas of reason. 

KANT

Theoretical Reason

Practical

Reason

Aesthetic Reason

 

Freedom to predict and control nature

Freedom from material determinants of action

 

 

Knowledge of the Natural

World

Moral Ordering of Action in the  Social World

Artistic

apprehension of self & world not subordinate to knowledge or right action

Coordinate status of theoretical, practical and aesthetic reason reshuffled to "complete" Kant's turn to "world-forming subjectivity."

FICHTE

 

Freedom for forming different world-experiences

 

SCHILLER

 

 

Freedom within the world to apprehend living form

World-constituting synthesis fused with logical self-historization: Hegel, Marx, and Kierkegaard attempt, each in his own way, to lay claim to the medium of history in order to conceive of the unity of a historicized world as process -- whether it be the unity of the world as a whole, or of the human world, or of the life history of the individual." (PMT, p. 117).

HEGEL

Absolute freedom or ÒspiritÓ as the self-development of an in-finitizing or de-limiting being.  Freedom toward infinite removal of all limitations.

 

 

Self-historicizing World-constituting synthesis fused with Labor

MARX

MATERIAL ACTIVITY OF PRODUCING LIFE'S CONDITIONS = LABOR: Survival, overcoming alienation, utopian labor as artistic activity.  Freedom toward our communal Òspecies being.Ó

"It was secularized confessional literature, for which Rousseau provided the great example, that recalled that the basic concepts of rational psychology had never gotten a hold on the fundamental experience of the Judeo-Christian tradition, despite the kinship of metaphysics with theology.  The experience to which I am referring is the individuating gaze of that transcendent God, simultaneously grudging and merciful, before whom every individual, alone an irreplaceable, must answer for his life as whole.  This individuating power of the consciousness of sin, which could not be captured by the concepts of philosophy, sought for itself a different, literary form of expression in the autobiographical revelation of one's life story, as the published documentation of an existence that has always to answer for itself.  In addition, the theme of ineffable individuality takes on new relevance as historical thinking comes on the scene." (PMT, p. 127).

KIERKEGAARD

ÒIn relating itself to itself and in willing to be itself, the self rests transparently in the power that established it.Ó  Freedom from despair.

 

NIETZSCHE

The will to power